TL;DR
Astral Codex Ten published Open Thread 456, a weekly community post combining reader discussion with notices about meetups, election guides and projects related to AI. The post also asks AI and grantmaking experts to complete a survey and describes a new real-money prediction market focused on AI.
Astral Codex Ten published Open Thread 456, its weekly open discussion post, with updates on local meetups, election resources and projects involving AI funding and information sharing. The post asks people familiar with AI safety and grantmaking to assess the value of roughly 80 possible accomplishments, and highlights a new prediction market focused on AI companies.
Prime made for students and young adults
- Fast, free delivery for dorm and study essentials
- Prime Video and Amazon Music included
- Member-only deals
The thread invites readers to ask questions and discuss any topic. It also points to the blog’s unofficial subreddit, Discord and bulletin board, along with in-person meetups. The post lists meetup changes in Rockville, Northampton, Eindhoven, Great Barrington, Cairo, Portland and Sofia, directing readers to the original post for details.
The author says the Boston ACX meetup group has completed a Greater Boston general-election voting guide and may produce more guides during the following week. Work on a possible Bay Area guide was still under consideration. The post says the San Francisco mail-in ballot registration deadline was the end of that Monday and identifies Scott Wiener for Congress as the group’s main San Francisco endorsement.
For an ongoing effort to model parts of AI grantmaking, the author requests survey responses from people experienced in AI and grantmaking. The survey asks respondents to assign utility weights to about 80 AI safety accomplishments. A second, optional version asks participants to predict how the author would answer the first survey, a design the author says could help distinguish differences in worldview from random variation in choices.
Community Notices Meet AI Funding Research
The post combines routine community coordination with requests that could inform how AI safety funding priorities are modeled. Responses to the survey may give the author data on how knowledgeable participants value different kinds of accomplishments. The post does not report findings or claim that the survey will determine grant awards; it is a request for input as part of continuing work.
The other announcements give readers practical ways to participate in local groups and related online projects. The voting guide and registration reminder concern election participation, while the meetup notices provide information for community members in several cities. The thread also introduces projects that apply online tools to AI markets and public note-taking, extending the post’s focus beyond discussion within the blog itself.
These updates are presented as announcements rather than as independently evaluated results. Readers should distinguish the author’s description of project aims from evidence about how well the projects work, which the thread does not provide.
Popular right now

KitchenAid 5.5 Qt Bowl-Lift Stand Mixer – Porcelain White (KSM55SXXX)

Ninja CM371 Hot & Iced XL Coffee Maker with Rapid Cold Brew

KitchenAid Artisan 5-Quart Tilt-Head Stand Mixer, Almond Cream
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Thread’s Community Format
Open Thread 456 follows the format described by Astral Codex Ten: a recurring public space for open discussion, accompanied by a collection of notices from the blog’s community. The post says most content on the site is free, while some is subscriber-only. It also points readers to several informal community channels and local gatherings.
The thread places the AI grantmaking survey within a continuing effort by the author to model—and possibly someday automate—some parts of grantmaking. It refers readers to earlier work but does not summarize its methods or results in this post. The current survey is therefore a request for data, not a report that an automated funding system has been built or adopted.
Two other projects are described by their proponents. Stephen Grugett, identified in the thread as a grantee and Manifold Markets co-founder, announced MNX, a real-money prediction market on AI. The post says it allows users to trade futures tied to AI company stocks, bet on company revenues and make predictions about measures such as Epoch Capabilities Index targets. Separately, Goodheart Labs is developing Common Notes, described as a community-note system intended to work across websites using AI-written notes, user contributions and user votes, with a browser extension.
“This is the weekly visible open thread. Post about anything you want, ask random questions, whatever.”
— Astral Codex Ten post
Survey Results and Project Details
The post does not give a deadline for the AI safety survey, say how many responses have been collected, or report any results. It also does not explain how the responses will be analyzed or whether they will affect actual grant decisions. The author frames automation as a possible future direction, not a completed outcome.
Several other details remain open. The author says a Bay Area election guide is still being considered, and the post does not confirm whether additional endorsements will follow. It points readers to the original thread for the specific meetup changes, but does not reproduce their full details here. The post also does not provide operational or performance data for MNX or Common Notes.
The prediction-market price comparison is presented as an observation in the post: it says Polymarket and MNX both still price Anthropic around $2 trillion despite discussion of a fall from $2 trillion to $1.5 trillion. The thread does not provide a date range, contract details, or a comparison baseline for those figures, so they should not be treated as independently verified valuations or as evidence of a measured market trend.
Upcoming Meetups and Survey Responses
The author says a Bay Area ACX meetup is scheduled for Saturday, October 24, at 1 p.m. at Mox, 1680 Mission Street in San Francisco, and expects to publish a separate post about it. Readers seeking updates to the other city meetups are directed to the original thread.
People with relevant AI and grantmaking experience can complete the utility-weight survey and, if they have time, the alternate prediction survey. The author says the alternate responses could help separate differences in worldview from random noise in the first survey. The post does not set a date for sharing analysis or describe a later decision based on the data.
The author says more election guides or endorsements may appear in the coming week, while noting that the Bay Area guide remains uncertain. MNX and Common Notes are presented as projects readers can explore through links in the post; no launch milestones or subsequent updates are specified there.
Key Questions
What is Open Thread 456?
It is a weekly Astral Codex Ten open discussion post that invites readers to raise questions or talk about any topic and includes community announcements.
What does the AI grantmaking survey ask?
It asks people experienced in AI and grantmaking to assign utility weights to about 80 AI safety accomplishments. An optional second survey asks participants to predict how the author would answer the first.
What is MNX?
The post describes MNX as a real-money prediction market on AI, with futures linked to AI company stocks, bets on company revenues and targets such as Epoch Capabilities Index measures. The thread does not independently evaluate the service.
When and where is the Bay Area meetup?
The post schedules it for Saturday, October 24, at 1 p.m. at Mox, 1680 Mission Street in San Francisco, and says a separate announcement may follow.
Is a Bay Area election guide confirmed?
No. The author says they are still trying to determine whether a guide can be prepared. The post identifies Scott Wiener for Congress as the group’s main San Francisco endorsement, but says there may be more later.
Source: rss
